The National Energy Board is allowing Kinder Morgan to keep parts of its emergency management plan for the Trans Mountain pipeline system redacted for commercial, security and privacy reasons, despite the provincial government's insistence on more details.
The provincial government asked for the missing information, along with an oil spill response plan, in Dec. 5 motion filed with the NEB.
"The province has found the redactions made by Trans Mountain to be excessive, unjustified and prohibitive. The redactions thwart the province's examination of the EMP (emergency management program) documents, and preclude a thorough understanding of Trans Mountain's EMP by the board and all intervenors," the government's motion reads.
Some of the missing information includes people's names and phones numbers, bomb threat checklists and valve locations. A section on the Burnaby tank farm is missing information on site drainage and maps for the terminal and the evacuation zone.
But in a decision released last Thursday, the NEB sided with Kinder Morgan.
"In this instance, the board is satisfied that sufficient information has been filed from the existing EMP documents to meet the board's requirements at this stage in the process," the response reads. The board went on to explain that the province will be privy to some of the missing documents as Kinder Morgan consults "implicated parties" to update the plans for the proposed pipeline expansion.
Pending NEB approval, Kinder Morgan plans to twin the Trans Mountain pipeline, which would nearly triple the line's capacity from 300,000 barrels per day to 890,000, while increasing tanker traffic nearly seven fold.
As for the oil spill response plan, the NEB cited Kinder Morgan's line - that it can't file what it doesn't have - because Kinder Morgan is waiting for information from Western Canada Marine Response Corporation, the company in charge of cleaning up oil spills on water.
Several municipalities wrote to the NEB in support of the province's request for more information, including Burnaby, Vancouver, Surrey, Langley, Abbotsford, North Vancouver and West Vancouver, as well as First Nations bands and environmental groups.
Kinder Morgan filed most of its emergency management plan with the NEB last October, which means the documents are publicly available through the board's website. Kinder Morgan initially wanted to keep the documents secret for proprietary reasons, which the NEB sometimes allows. In this case, the board ruled that public interest outweighed Kinder Morgan's request to keep the plan confidential.